Assignment
Major Writing Project : Joining a Conversation You've Researched (5-6 pages)
• Write a researched argument about an issue affecting your future career field, your major field, or your community, or focus on an issue described in the readings you've done from the book. This paper is your own argument, but you should take into account what you've learned during this course: begin by showing the conversation your paper is responding to ("they say"), have a clear statement of your own argument about the issue ("I say"), include quotes and incorporate them smoothly (both in the "they say" and "I say" paragraphs), point out possible objections to your argument, use appropriate transitions, and explain why the issue matters (so what? who cares?). You must use at least 5 sources and at least 2 must be from academic peer reviewed journals.
Recommended structure: For this paper you have 5-6 pages to work with and you need to include, in effect, five major parts:
1. Introduction: includes an overview of the conversation (names of key authors and the issues you're bringing up), a brief statement of your argument (or thesis statement), and a brief explanation of why your argument matters
2. summary of 2 or 3 authors or arguments, with quotes as evidence
3. summary of how they agree/disagree; provide quotes if necessary
4. your own opinion and your reasons for your opinion (which includes at least one naysayer); provide quotes as evidence
5. Conclusion: includes a return sentence, a restatement of your argument, and a developed explanation of why your argument matters
Note that these are five parts, not paragraphs (exceptions: the introduction and the conclusion are usually one paragraph each). What could this look like? Here's an example: After the brief introductory paragraph (where you introduce your topic, an overview of the conversation you're entering, a sense of your argument and briefly why your argument matters), you might have a summary of one author (1 paragraph), then a summary of the second author (1 paragraph), and a summary of another author or position (1 paragraph). Then you might have one paragraph that explains how they agree or disagree (though you can already allude to that in the summary paragraphs through phrases like "Unlike X, Y asserts that..."). Note that the paragraph that explains how the authors or arguments agree or disagree is still "they say," since you're not yet putting forward your own opinion on the issues. At that point you'll have written about 3 pages. Then you write your own argument ("I say") in relation to the conversation you've set up (about two pages). At that point you've written about 5 pages. Then you end with a concluding paragraph, where you wrap it up with a return sentence and again explain why it matters.