Problem
(i) If I stumble into you and break your nose, is that a voluntary or involuntary act according to Aristotle? Why?
(ii) What is an example of an act done under constraint? Is such an act voluntary?
(iii) If someone reveals a secret that he didn't know was a secret, has he revealed the secret voluntarily? Why or why not, according to Aristotle?
(iv) How do choice and deliberation relate? Why can't I deliberate about "solstices and sunrises"?
(v) Why do you think Aristotle would say it's inappropriate to blame a horse or a dog or a young child for what it does?