Part 1
Consider the scenario from the perspective of (1) the police, (2) the courts, and (3) corrections. From each perspective, answer the following questions:
Where would discretion be appropriate?
Where would discretion not be appropriate?
Give an example of how discretion (if used in this capacity) could change the outcome of the case.
Part 2
In the context of the United States criminal justice system, select any 2 of the questions listed below. Your response should provide sufficient detail on each of the topics, and you should address the topic of discretion within the criminal justice system.
What factors influence the exercise of discretion?
What are some of the methods for controlling discretion?
What are some ethical considerations for discretion?
Do you think there is too much discretion in the criminal justice system? Explain.
Do you think it would be desirable to limit the amount of discretion in the criminal justice system? If so, how would you do it? What might be the effects?