Case Scenario: Pretend you are an attorney for a company and the following situation has occurred. A man carrying a briefcase was getting on a train while it was just starting to move. The train-worker grabbed him by the arm and helped him onto the train. The man dropped the briefcase, which was full of dynamite, and it exploded near a coin change machine which dropped onto a nearby female passenger, nearly killing her.
Explain as if you were an attorney for the train company, on what grounds should you not be liable for the injury.
Go through each of the 4 elements of Negligence and explain which one the train company fails to meet in order to be liable.