Assignment:
Knowledge management and supporting tools for collaborative networks
Recent organisational trends show an increase in the formation of collaborative networks (CNs) to improve competitive advantage and provide world-class excellence and flexibility to address dynamic and turbulent market conditions. Collaboration of various forms can increase profits by improving chances to capture valuable business opportunities, address market demands and share resources and competencies in very competitive and rapidly changing environments. CNs can take a variety of forms, including highly integrated and dynamic supply chains, extended and virtual enter- prises, virtual organisations, collaborative virtual laboratories, professional virtual communities, and virtual organisation breeding environments and collaboration pools.
A major reason for collaboration is to exploit the core competencies of all the enterprises concerned, to form strategic alliances and enhance competitiveness by integrating value-added activities, information, resources and knowledge between enterprises. These benefits are enabled by the advances in Information and Communication technology (ICT)-based infrastructure and services. For more than a decade, the European Commission has been funding several projects in the area of ICT tools, techniques, methods and infrastructure for CNs. Currently, enterprises are adopting advanced ICT solutions for gathering, storing, organising and accessing enterprise knowledge easily.
In the era of the knowledge economy and knowledge-based competition, an efficient and adaptive CN must be able to secure various types of knowledge assets and maximise its strategic values. Effective knowledge management within a CN is central to its success. To enhance the activities of a networked enterprise in the successful, timely creation of and participation in a CN, tools, techniques and processes are needed to capture, share, reuse and apply various types of knowledge relevant to the various stages of the collaboration lifecycle. Several authors have highlighted the need for developing knowledge management systems to integrate the information which must be exchanged or shared between the network partners and external knowledge they require on a common platform. Effective knowledge management is essential to improve the productivity and the quality of decisions taken by the member organisations.
A critical aspect of effective knowledge management within CNs is the identification and capture of the most appropriate knowledge for reuse or exploitation in a particular context combined with the most efficient tools and mechanisms for its identification, sharing or transfer. With these capabilities, an enterprise can improve its decision-making ability and capacity to with stand systemic discontinuities and can adapt to new risk environments.
The enterprise can also effectively align its strategies, operations, management systems and decision support capabilities so that it can uncover and adjust to continually changing risks, endure disruptions to primary earning drivers and create an advantage over less adaptive competitors. In addition, particularly because of the high importance of small and medium sized enterprises (SMEs) within such collab- orative networks, this knowledge must be readily available through services, tools and technologies which are user-cen- tric, interoperable, reliable and affordable. Therefore, knowledge-based tools, methods, infrastructures and services are needed to achieve effective collaboration in a CN.
Bearing in mind all these challenges and aspirations, this special issue is mainly focused on gathering the state of the art in research and technology for knowledge management and supporting tools, methods and services for collabora- tive networks. In addition, this special issue also identifies and reports several future research directions, interesting top- ics and challenges.
This special issue has received very strong interest from researchers working in the area of knowledge management and supporting tools, methods and services for collaborative networks. We have received 60 papers from researchers and practitioners located in different parts of the world. After several rounds of peer review by two to three reviewers, 17 papers were selected for publication in this special issue.
These 17 papers address and exemplify a variety of related aspects in developing knowledge-management-based methods, tools, techniques and systems to support various kinds of collaborative networks. Various aspects of knowledge management issues have been discussed in a range of areas, including collaborative supply chain integration, decision models for SME CNs, buyer-suppler collaboration, design col- laboration patents, collaborative commerce adoption, reference frameworks for CNs, collaborative tools for SMEs, new product development, supply chain control logic, product supply chains decarbonisation, SME production customisation, collaborative decision making, competence modelling for VOs, flexible supply networks, high-value manufacturing and a collaborative approach for supply chain operational risk mitigation. A short description of each article is discussed below.
The first article of this issue "A Holistic View of Knowledge Integration in Collaborative Supply Chains", by Jayaram and Pathak (2013), discusses a knowledge integration mechanism in collaborative supply chains. They propose two different types of mechanisms within a collaborative supply chain: short-term knowledge sharing and iterative knowledge enrichment. They use data from a large and diverse set of 432 new product development (NPD) projects, and investigate the effects of knowledge sharing and enrichment between firms and their collaborative network partners on product concept effectiveness and process performance.
Their findings suggest that knowledge sharing and enrich- ment are significant mechanisms for enterprise-wide knowledge integration in collaborative networks. In addition, upstream knowledge sharing and enrichment has a significant influence on both product concept effectiveness and man- ufacturing process performance, over and above the effects of downstream knowledge sharing and enrichment.
The second article, by Renna (2013), "Decision Model to Support the SME's Decision to Participate or Leave a Collaborative Network" proposes a decision model to support enterprises in their decisions to participate in or exit from a network of enterprises. The model is based on the definition of a set of rules that operate with local information to make decisions and integrate the collaboration methodology and the decision model. This environment is related to independent plants that cooperate with reduced information sharing. A simulation environment has been developed to test the proposed approach and the simulation results have shown that the proposed approach is a very promising tool to support an enterprise's participation decisions in a collaborative network.
The article "Harnessing Value in Knowledge Management for Performance in Buyer-Supplier Collaboration", by Yang (2013), investigates how different knowledge-management processes (i.e. knowledge acquisition and dissemina- tion) affect manufacturers' performance in collaborative economic exchanges with their suppliers. Drawing upon the knowledge-based view and transaction cost economics, this article proposes that knowledge-management processes are positively related to the performance of manufacturers in collaborative buyer-supplier relationships. It also proposes that this link is stronger when the levels of supply chain integration and relational stability are higher rather than lower.
The next article, "Ontology-Based Neural Network for Patent Knowledge Management in Design Collaboration", by Trappey et al. (2013), discusses and proposes a novel knowledge-management approach using an ontology-based artifi- cial neural network (ANN) algorithm to automatically classify and search for knowledge documents stored in huge online patent corpuses. They focus on developing a smart and semantic-oriented classification and search from the sources of the most critical and well-structured knowledge publications, namely patents, to gain valuable and practical references for the collaborative networks of technology-centric product and production development teams.
This research provides an advanced semanticoriented search algorithm to accurately identify related patent documents in the patent knowledge base. The results have been compared with the previous automatic classification methods and have outperformed earlier methods.
The article "Do Interorganisational Relationships and Knowledge-Management Practices Enhance Collaborative Commerce Adoption?", by Chong et al. (2013) aims to investigate the contributions of interorganisational relationships and knowledge management practices as predictors of collaborative commerce (c-commerce) adoption. A survey was undertaken in 136 firms for this research and a non-compensatory adoption decision process was modelled using a neu-ral network approach to examine the predictors of c-commerce adoption. The results show that both interorganisational relationships and knowledge management processes play an important role in predicting the adoption of c-commerce. The findings lead to an understanding of what attributes of interorganisational relationships and knowledge management processes can contribute to the improved adoption of c-commerce in the supply chain.
The next article "The Application of a Knowledge-Based Reference Framework to Support the Provision of Requi- site Variety and Customisation Across Collaborative Networks", by Lyons et al. (2013), concerns the discussion and application of a knowledge-based reference framework to demonstrate how product variety and customisation can be supported across different forms of collaborative customer-supplier networks. In addition, explanations are provided on how collaborative networks can be classified, how their adaptive capabilities can be established, and the characteristics and attributes that particular types of networks require in order to handle their commitment to the provision of variety and customisation.
The article "Collaboration Networks and Collaboration Tools: A Match for SMEs?", by Michaelides et al. (2013), discusses the role of the Internet as an enabling technology for virtual collaboration networks of SMEs for problem- solving and innovative idea exchange. This research seeks to examine how informal interactions are facilitated in SMEs through Web 2.0 tools. They examine how Web 2.0 affects the collaborative effort in two SME CNs; this study demonstrated that the collaboration effort is amplified when Web 2.0 tools are available. Other parameters such as trust in other members' abilities, perception of usefulness and enhancement of collective knowledge are seen as supporting the mutual relationship of CNs. In addition, the study brings together the three diverse research areas of collaborative networks, Internet collaborative tools and psychological barriers and enablers.
The next article, "A Collaborative Framework to Minimise Knowledge Loss in New Product Development", by Shankar et al. (2013), highlights that in rapidly changing dynamic and multi-layered environments, recognising, manag- ing and preventing knowledge loss (K-loss) can be a key determinant of an organisation's success. This research argues for a collaborative network structure within organisations to prevent knowledge loss in new product development. They developed an in-depth case study of six Indian auto component manufacturing companies to identify the sources of K-loss.
Based on their observation and case studies, this article recommends ways to create collaboration pools that increase the flows of information and communication and help mitigate knowledge loss throughout the value chain. This article also summarises the researchers' findings as usable rules of thumb for helping senior and middle-level managers develop and leverage collaborative networks for effectively managing knowledge loss for their organisations.
The next article "Knowledge Sharing in Collaborative Supply Chains: Twin Effects of Trust and Power", by Cai et al. (2013), discusses the mechanisms underpinning knowledge sharing in supply chains, specifically knowledge shar- ing in a dyadic buyer-supplier relationship. This research highlights that trust and power are two important antecedents of two types of knowledge sharing between a buyer and supplier, namely technical exchange and technology transfer.
This research uses a large-scale survey conducted from a contact list of 800 companies provided by the Singapore Logistics Association for case design. Structural equation modelling was used to derive results which suggest that trust has significant effects on technical exchange and technology transfer. Furthermore, power also affects technical exchange and technology transfer significantly, though the impacts appear to be weaker than for trust.
The next article, "Web-Services-Based Supply-Chain-Control Logic: An Automotive Case Study", by Makris and Chryssolouris (2013), discusses the design and implementation of a decision support software system based on web ser- vices capable of modelling the supply chain and querying the supply chain partners to provide information regarding the availability of parts required for the production of a highly customisable product. They also demonstrated the feasi- bility of implementing this approach in a typical automotive case study.
The article "Decarbonising Product Supply Chains: Design and Development of an Integrated Evidence-Based Deci- sion Support System - The Supply Chain Environmental Analysis Tool (SCEnAT)", by Koh et al. (2013), proposes a state-of-the-art decision support system (DSS) for carbon emissions accounting and management, mainly across product supply chains, by identifying methodological shortcomings in existing tools, and it establishes a supply chain (SC) framework which provides businesses with a holistic understanding of their supply chains and ensures that partners within supply chain collaborative networks have a shared understanding of their emissions.
It describes in detail the design and development of a DSS now known as supply chain environmental analysis tool. The methodological frame- work used to design and develop SCEnAT integrates different individual techniques/methods of SC mapping, SC carbon accounting, SC interventions and SC intervention evaluation on a range of key performance indicators (KPIs). Finally, it also demonstrates the application of SCEnAT, especially the advantage of using a robust carbon accounting methodol- ogy, to an SC case study.
Fornasiero and Zangiacomi (2013), in the next article "A Structured Approach for Customised Production in SME Collaborative Networks", aim to provide a reference model depicting its structure and the related tools for collaborative networks model for SMEs to address needs and expectations of specific target groups - such as elderly, obese, disabled or diabetic people - to customise functional and fashionable clothes and footwear that are of high quality, at an afford- able price and are eco-compatible. They aim to develop a new framework for the textile, clothing and footwear industry (TCFI) based on methods and tools for (co-)design, development, configuration, production and distribution of small order quantities in collaborative networks.
In the next article, "A Decision-Focused Knowledge Management Framework to Support Collaborative Decision Making for Lean Supply Chain Management", Liu et al. (2013) identify efficient knowledge management as one of the key requirements to achieve integrated support for lean supply chain decisions. This research proposes a decision- focused knowledge framework, including a multi-layer knowledge model (to capture the know-why and know-with together with the know-what and know-how), a knowledge matrix for knowledge elicitation and a decision tree for the design of the knowledge base.
A knowledge system for lean supply chain management (KSLSCM) has been developed using artificial intelligence system shells VisiRule and Flex. The knowledge framework and the KSLSCM have been evaluated through an industrial decision case. It has been demonstrated through the KSLSCM that the decision-focused knowledge framework can provide efficient and effective support for collaborative decision making in supply chain waste elimination.
Cheikhrouhou, Tawail, and Choudhary (2013) in the next article, "Modelling Competence-Based Virtual Organisations Using the Unified Enterprise Competence Modelling Language", introduce the principles for modelling competence-based virtual organisations by using a unified enterprise competence modelling language (UECML). Their proposed modelling approach and associated language provides a neutral interface to virtual organisation modelling based on competences, taking into account the multiple roles and entities participating in a virtual organisation, and therefore providing constructs covering processes, resources, competences and virtual organisation (VO) entities. A case study of the Swiss virtual organisations breeding environment Virtuelle Fabrik with regards to the project Abfallhai is presented and discussed, showing how the developed modelling language is adapted to model virtual organisations.
Smirnov et al. (2013) in the next article "Dynamic Configuration of Flexible Supply Networks (FSNs) Based on Semantic Service Composition" propose a novel approach to dynamic network members' discovery and selection based on competence profiles included in provided service descriptions. The approach is based on the idea of characterising all FSN members by their functions or services and describing them via profiles thus defining their roles. The profiles described by the application ontology are associated with agent-based services that negotiate to take into account expli- cit and tacit preferences of the enterprises, in order to dynamically configure a collaborative network on demand.
In the next article, "A Dynamic Knowledge Management Framework for the High Value Manufacturing Industry", Piorkowski et al. (2013) describe a dynamic KM framework in the context of employees being motivated to create profit for their company through product development in high value manufacturing. It is reported how the framework was dis- cussed during a meeting of the collaborating company's (BAE Systems') project stakeholders. The framework has been designed to support organisational learning and to reward employees at the start of the product lifecycle in order to improve the position of the company in the market place.
Finally, the last article "Supply Chain Operational Risk Mitigation: A Collaborative Approach", by Chen, Sohal, and Prajogo (2013), examines three types of risks, namely supply risk, demand risk and process risk, in relation to three types of collaboration, namely supplier collaboration, customer collaboration and internal collaboration, as a mechanism to mitigate those risks. The proposed relationship model is tested with data collected from 203 manufacturing companies in Australia. The results show that each area of collaboration effectively reduces its respective supply chain risk, but only the mitigation of process risk and demand risk has a direct effect on supply chain performance. In addition, both supply risk and demand risk increase process risk.
In summary, this special issue has collected research contributions from across the world from researchers and prac- titioners working in the area of knowledge management and supporting methods for collaborative networks. We are thankful to all the authors and the referees for their contributions to enhancing the quality of the articles in this special issue. Special thanks go to the past editor-in-chief, J.E. Middle and to the current editor-in-chief, Prof A. Dolgui for this opportunity and for their contributions in managing this special issue.