Question 1.Watching simulated child pornography is morally wrong. (Judgment)
Question 2. Engaging in simulated murder in video games is relevantly similar to watching simulated child pornography. (Analogy) Thus, engaging in simulated murder in video games is morally wrong. (Conclusion) Premise 2 is false because there is a disanalogy - unlike watching simulated child pornography, engaging in simulated murder in video games does not involve the sexual exploitation of vulnerable individuals. Test moral relevance. to test this difference for moral relevance, we must re-imagine the original described case in a way that eliminates the difference. in this case, that means imagining that Watching simulated child pornography is morally not wrong.