Problem:
Students are often asked to read a text and then share their interpretation of or conclusion about the text by writing a paragraph. Once they've finished reading a text such as a selection from early in a novel, we can give them a prompt with a prediction question like, "In the book Of Mice and Men, will George and Lennie ever be able to achieve their dream? Support your answer by writing a paragraph and offering three reasons." Students can construct their own yes or no answer in their mind and then ask an AI tool like ChatGPT for its answer. In groups, students should collaboratively read the ChatGPT response and assess it using a rubric that the teacher has provided for them. This will allow students to assess the quality of the AI response while also familiarizing them with the evaluation tool that the teacher will use to assess their work. Finally, individually, ask students to create a paragraph that is written to defend the opposite position. For example, if ChatGPT said that George and Lennie wouldn't be able to achieve their dream, students need to write a paragraph arguing that they would achieve their dream. This allows students to know what points support the opposite opinion and then develop rebuttal points that refute them. This provides students with the opportunity to gather and assess relevant information, which strengthens their critical thinking skills.