Discussion Board
Case Study Analysis: Right vs. Right
After reading the assigned Ethical Decision Making and Action resource and the professional standards for your field of study, select one of the following case studies to further analyze:
• Case Study 1: The Case of Bad News
• Case Study 2: The Case of the Performance Appraisal
• Case Study 3: Artificial Intelligence; Death and Dying
• Case Study 4: Educational Dilemmas (select one of the six cases presented)
Based on your selected case study, write a 350-word discussion board that addresses the following:
1) Identify the moral dilemma or ethical decision being presented.
2) Summarize the relevant facts.
3) Identify the type/types of right vs. right principle (as identified by Kidder in the Ethical Decision Making and Action resource) and justify your selection with citations from your reading.
a. Truth vs. loyalty
b. Individual vs. community
c. Short-term vs. long-term
d. Justice vs. mercy
4) Apply a recommended resolution considering the principles: rules-based, cares-based, ends based. Consider who wins and who loses, or propose a win-win alternative to the scenario.
The response should include a reference list. One-inch margins, Using Times New Roman 12 pnt font, double-space and APA style of writing and citations.