4. Collaborative: We de?ne the Escape Problem as follows. We are given a directed graph G = (V; E) (picture a network of roads.) A certain collection of vertices X V are designated as populated vertices, and a certain other collection S V are designated as safe vertices. (Assume that X and S are disjoint.) In case of an emergency, we want evacuation routes from the populated vertices to the safe vertices. A set of evacuation routes is de?ned as a set of paths in G such that (i) each vertex in X is the tail of one path, (ii) the last vertex on each path lies in S, and (iii) the paths do not share any edges. Such a set of paths gives way for the occupants of the populated vertices to "escape" to S without overly congesting any edge in G.
(a) Given G, X, and S, show how to decide in polynomial time whether such a set of evacuation routes exists.
(b) Suppose we have exactly the same problem as in (a), but we want to enforce an even stronger version of the "no congestion" condition (iii). Thus we change (iii) to say, "the paths do not share any vertices." With this new condition, show how to decide in polynomial time whether such a set of evacuation routes exists. Also provide an example with the same G, X, and S in which the answer is "yes" to the question in (a) but "no" to the question in (b).