Tasks:
Select three or four essays from your textbook relating to your area of experience and expertise (for example, finance, accounting, or technology).
Create a 10- to 12-page report critiquing your chosen readings.
Include a literature review of your chosen essays, starting with a synopsis of the major ideas and themes in each essay.
Conduct an in-depth critique of the essays by comparing and contrasting the essential points discussed in each work.
Include a reflective assessment of what lessons one can learn from the points brought up in the essays and how they can effectively be implemented in a typical business setting.
The following is a checklist that you can use in analyzing or critiquing your chosen essays:
Each piece of writing is different; but, in most cases, the majority of these questions are applicable. Use these questions as a point of reference for your critique. You may also cover other relevant aspects of an essay not addressed by the critique question list below:
Is the essay's title a clear depiction of its content? Why or why not?
Is the author qualified to write about the subject matter?
What is the purpose of the essay? Is it stated clearly?
Identify the problem statement in the essay. Does the introduction and conclusion focus clearly on the problem statement?
Is the statement of facts (beyond commonly known facts) supported by appropriate citations in the text and/or references?
Which ideas in the essay need further development?
What ideas in the essay are practical enough to be implemented in a business setting and which ideas are rather impractical? Why?
Does the essay contain discursive or irrelevant sections? If yes, what are they?
Is the work biased in any way? Examine the author's biases.
Is there an idea that is common to all the essays?
How is the essay different from the other essay(s) you are also critiquing?
Complete the tasks pertaining to the chosen topic.