Problem
Readings: Michael O. Hardimon, "Minimalist Biological Race," John H. Relethford, Biological Anthropology, Population Genetics, and Race, Jorge J.E. Gracia, "Race and Ethnicity." All in Oxford Handbook.
There is a problem with the meaningfulness of "race" as a concept, given the absence of a biological foundation for racial differences that people in society believe are biological. Contrast the views of Hardimon and Relethford and briefly comment on Gracia's proposed solution.