Article- Quality of service in an information economy.
Is the purpose of article and research problem clearly identified?
What was the main theme of the paper?
What new ideas or information were communicated in the paper?
Why was it important to publish these ideas?
Did the author clearly define the research process used in their article?
What methods did the authors use to reach conclusions?
If this is an experiment or survey, how were the data collected and analyzed?
Who were the subjects? What were the basic results or findings from the research?
If this is an opinion paper, where did the author find his or her opinions?
If this is a technical paper, how do you know that the material is accurate? Give your impressions of the usefulness of the paper.
Give your reasons for your opinions.
Write about your opinions of the strengths and weaknesses of the paper in separate paragraphs.
Does the author of the study protect the participants in the study and is the scope of the study clearly defined?
Did the author adequately define the limitations of the study and how these limitations could have an impact on the finding of the study?
Can the findings of this article be applied to the needs of the research in progress?
Were the findings important to a reader?
Were the conclusions valid? Do you agree with the conclusions?
If the material was technical, was the technical material innovative?
Is the data and finding of this article sufficiently current to be applicable to the research in progress?
Does the author present their findings and recommendation in an unbiased manner?
Are the findings consistent with the purpose of the research and the title of the article?
Are the conclusions presented from the data presented in the study and the analysis performed justified to support the recommendations?
Are the researcher's background, experience and credentials presented with the report?