Assignment:Analyzing Characters
Look at the characters in the story and describe how they are revealed through the combination of direct methods of image, voice, action, thought, and/or indirect authorial interpretation.
Analyze and evaluate how the point of view works in relationship to the methods of characterization.
Be certain to use details from the story to illustrate your observations
The story I chose was Sitting with the dead by William Trevor.
Here is an excerpt from the story:
Read an Excerpt
Sitting with the Dead
His eyes had been closed and he opened them, saying he wanted to see the stable-yard.
Emily's expression was empty of response. Her face, younger than his and yet not seeming so, was empty of everything except the tiredness she felt. 'From the window?' she said.
No, he'd go down, he said. 'Will you get me the coat? And have the boots by the door.'
She turned away from the bed. He would manage on his own if she didn't help him: she'd known him for twenty-eight years, been married to him for twenty-three. Whether or not she brought the coat up to him would make no difference, any more than it would if she protested.
'It could kill you,' she said.
'The fresh air'd strengthen a man.'
Downstairs, she placed the boots ready for him at the back door. She brought his cap and muffler to him with his overcoat. A stitch was needed where the left sleeve met the shoulder, she noticed. She hadn't before and knew he wouldn't wait while she repaired it now.
'What're you going to do there?' she asked, and he said nothing much. Tidy up a bit, he said.
He died eight days later, and Dr Ann explained that tidying the stable-yard with only a coat over his pyjamas wouldn't have hastened anything. An hour after she left, the Geraghtys came to the house, not knowing that he was dead.
It was half past seven in the evening then. At the same time the next morning, Keane the undertaker was due. She said that to the Geraghtys, making sure they understood, not wanting them to think she was turning them away for some other reason. Although she knew that if her husband had been alive he wouldn't have agreed to have the Geraghtys at his bedside. It was a relief that they had come too late.
The Geraghtys were two middle-aged women, sisters, the Misses Geraghty, who sat with the dying. Emily had heard of them, but did not know them, not even to see: they'd had to give their name when she opened the door to them. It had never occurred to her that the Geraghtys would attempt to bring their good works to the sick-room she had lived with herself for the last seven months. They were Legion of Mary women, famed for their charity, tireless in their support of the Society of St Vincent de Paul and their promulgation of the writings of Father Xavier O'Shea, a local priest who, at a young age in the 1880s, had contracted malaria in the mission fields of the East.
'We only heard of your trouble Tuesday,' the thinner and smaller of the two apologized. 'It does happen the occasional time we wouldn't hear.'
The other woman, more robust and older, allowed herself jewellery and make-up and took more care with her clothes. But it was her quiet, sharp-featured sister who took the lead.
'We heard in MacClincy's,' she said.
'I'm sorry you've had a wasted journey.'
'It's never wasted.' There was a pause, as if a pause was necessary here. 'You have our sympathy,' was added to that, the explanation of why the journey had not been in vain.
The conversation took place entirely at the hall door. Dusk was becoming dark, but over the white-washed wall of the small front garden Emily still could see a car drawn up in the road. It was cold, the wind gone round to the east. They meant well, these women, even if they'd got everything wrong, driving out from Carra to visit a man who wouldn't have welcomed them and then arriving too late, a man whose death had spared them an embarrassment.
'Would you like a cup of tea?' Emily offered.
She imagined they'd refuse and then begin to go, saying they couldn't disturb her at a time like this. But the big, wide-shouldered one glanced at her sister, hesitating.
'If you're alone,' the smaller one said, 'you'd be welcome to our company. If it would be of help to you.'
The dead man had been without religion. Anyone could have told them that, Emily reflected, making tea. He would have said that there was more to their sitting at the bedsides of the ill than met the eye, and she wondered if that could possibly be so. Did they in their compassionate travels hope for the first signs of the belief that often came out of nowhere when death declared its intention? Did they drive away from the houses they visited, straight to a presbytery, their duty done? She had never heard that said about the Geraghtys and she didn't want to believe it. They meant well, she said to herself again.
When they left, she wouldn't go back upstairs to look at the dead features. She'd leave him now to Keane in the morning. In the brief time that had elapsed a day had been settled for the funeral, Thursday of next week; in the morning she would let a few people know; she'd put a notice in the Advertiser. No children had been born: when Thursday had passed everything would be over except for the unpaid debts. She buttered slices of brack and stirred the tea in the pot. She carried in the tray.
They hadn't taken their coats off, but sat as still as statues, a little apart from one another.
'It's cold,' she said, 'I'll light the fire.'
'Ah no. Ah no, don't bother.' They both protested, but she did anyway, and the kindling that had been in the grate all summer flared up at once. She poured their tea, asking if they took sugar, and then offering the brack. They began to call her Emily, as if they knew her well. They gave their own names: Kathleen the older sister, and Norah.
'I didn't think,' Kathleen began to say, and Norah interrupted her.
'Oh, we know all right,' she said. 'You're Protestant here, but that never made a difference yet.'
They had sat with the Methodist minister, the Reverend Wolfe, Kathleen said. They'd read to him, they'd brought in whatever he wanted. They were there when he went.
'Never a difference,' Norah repeated, and in turn they took a slice of brack. They commented on it, saying it was excellent.
'It isn't easy,' Kathleen said when the conversation lapsed. 'The first few hours. We often stay.'
'It was good of you to think of him.'
'It's cheerful with that fire, Emily,' Kathleen said.
They asked her about the horses because the horses were what they'd heard about, and she explained that they'd become a thing of the past. She'd sell the place now, she said.
'You'd find it remote, Emily,' Kathleen said. Her lipstick had left a trace on the rim of the teacup and Norah drew her attention to it with a gesture. Kathleen wiped it off. 'We're town people ourselves,' she said.
Emily didn't consider the house she'd lived in for nearly thirty years remote. Five minutes in the car and you were in the middle of Carra. Mangan's Bridge, in the other direction, was no more than a minute.
'You get used to a place,' Emily said.
Story Analysis 3, due Saturday, 20 points
Write 350 to 450 words for this assignment using an MS Word file formatted in
Choose any of the stories assigned as reading throughout the course that you have not yet used in a story analysis.
1. Identify the point of view as first person with either a central or peripheral narrator OR third person omniscient, limited omniscient, or objective. Explain how you have identified the point of view with examples from the story.
2. Look at the characters in the story and describe how they are revealed through the combination of direct methods of image, voice, action, thought, and/or indirect authorial interpretation.
Analyze and evaluate how the point of view works in relationship to the methods of characterization.
Be certain to use details from the story to illustrate your observations.