--%>

Testing Functional structure models

Testing Functional structure models: It is often hard to tell whether the functional model structure chosen (which almost always in published work appears to generate consistent and robust results) is the only one tested or not.

Leamer (1983) has argued that good method should require that authors report how many regressions they undertook (and the functional forms subsequently rejected) before they found the one they chose to report. Leamer is particularly concerned that authors often will do hundreds or thousands of regressions (involving an array of functional forms and manipulations of assumptions and data) before they find one that offers statistically significant results. He believes that presenting only the one that worked, instead of talking about the hundreds or thousands that didn’t work is incomplete reporting and can lead to spurious results or at least misapplied confidence in the results.

He illustrates using an example of fertilizer usage on farms that multiple functional forms can work (i.e. a linear relationship or a quadratic relationship with either increasing or decreasing returns to scale). In many cases there is not enough data (or degrees of freedom) to properly test the functional forms and select among them (what he calls the “identification problem”).

He believes the job of any researcher is “to report economically and informatively the mapping from assumptions into inferences”, identifying which forms are accepted or rejected and why. By this he hopes researchers can reduce the “whimsical character of econometric inference.”

   Related Questions in Microeconomics

  • Q : Monopolistic competition in the long run

    In the past 4 decades, the still increasing globalization of trade has caused the United State automobile market to evolve by: (i) highly concentrated oligopoly towards monopolistic competition. (ii) pure monopoly to pure competition. (iii) a cartel t

  • Q : Least likely monopsony power Which of

    Which of the given below employers is LEAST likely to encompass monopsony power? (1) The secretarial service firm in the Los Angeles. (2) The police force in Eau Claire, Wisconsin. (3) U.S. Department of Defense. (4) Wal-Mart in the Snowflake, Arizona. (5) Community h

  • Q : Incentive to work and earn income The

    The incentive to work and earn income is likely to be least powerful if an individual who faces. (w) low income tax rates. making the cost of leisure high, and who possesses important amounts of valuable human capital. (x) high effect

  • Q : Marginal revenue product curve I have a

    I have a problem in economics on Marginal revenue product curve. Please help me in the following question. Demand for the labor through a monopolist in the product market is its: (i) Value of the marginal product (or VMP) curve. (ii) Marginal revenue

  • Q : Synonym of Word Inequity Of the given,

    Of the given, the closest synonym for the word inequity is: (w) inequality. (x) disproportional. (y) unfairness. (z) regressivity. Can someone explain/help me with best solution about problem of Economics

  • Q : A purely competitive industry long-run

    The long-run dynamics of purely competitive industry make sure that:( w) surviving firms make positive economic profits. (x) accounting profits will equal economic profits. (y) accounting profits will be zero. (z) economic profits will be zero. <

  • Q : Policies for overall demanding labor

    Policies which raise the overall demand for labor and maintain unemployment rates low are: (w) significant for the success of any other programs to reduce poverty. (x) sufficient measures to reduce the incidence of poverty. (y) not relevant to the suc

  • Q : Why production possibilities curve

    What is the reason that production possibilities curve concave? Elucidate.

  • Q : Economies of scale in natural monopoly

    Economies of scale which are substantial relative to market demand result within the market evolving to a: (w) contestable market. (x) collusive oligopoly. (y) natural monopoly. (z) "high tech" industry.

    Q : Resource market in equilibrium When the

    When the resource market demonstrated in this figure is into equilibrium: (1) owners of these resources currently receive no economic rents. (2) economic rent is specified from trapezoid Oade. (3) the rectangle Obde measures consumer surplus by the fi