--%>

Testing Functional structure models

Testing Functional structure models: It is often hard to tell whether the functional model structure chosen (which almost always in published work appears to generate consistent and robust results) is the only one tested or not.

Leamer (1983) has argued that good method should require that authors report how many regressions they undertook (and the functional forms subsequently rejected) before they found the one they chose to report. Leamer is particularly concerned that authors often will do hundreds or thousands of regressions (involving an array of functional forms and manipulations of assumptions and data) before they find one that offers statistically significant results. He believes that presenting only the one that worked, instead of talking about the hundreds or thousands that didn’t work is incomplete reporting and can lead to spurious results or at least misapplied confidence in the results.

He illustrates using an example of fertilizer usage on farms that multiple functional forms can work (i.e. a linear relationship or a quadratic relationship with either increasing or decreasing returns to scale). In many cases there is not enough data (or degrees of freedom) to properly test the functional forms and select among them (what he calls the “identification problem”).

He believes the job of any researcher is “to report economically and informatively the mapping from assumptions into inferences”, identifying which forms are accepted or rejected and why. By this he hopes researchers can reduce the “whimsical character of econometric inference.”

   Related Questions in Microeconomics

  • Q : Powerful negative externalities in

    Potentially powerful negative externalities are mainly overwhelmingly a decisive argument against permitting laissez faire policies and supplies to govern the production and market demands and distribution of: (1) avian flu antivirus shots. (2) public

  • Q : Efficiency Wages-Expected losses

    Expected losses to the workers from shirking are raised when a firm accepts a policy of: (1) Dividing the productive tasks and hence the division of labor is optimal. (2) Paying the efficiency wages which surpass market-clearing wages. (3) Avoiding the legal liability

  • Q : Problem on price elasticity The firm’s

    The firm’s net revenue grows whenever the price of a good is cut when the price elasticity of: (i) Demand surpass the price elasticity of supply. (ii) Replacement goods are less than one. (iii) Supply is in an associatively elastic range. (iv) D

  • Q : A monopolist in market power A

    A monopolist: (w) is a price taker in the sale of its product. (x) can charge any price this wishes without reducing profit. (y) is not a price taker into the sale of its product. (z) may or may not be a price taker within the sale of its product.

  • Q : Price charging by minimizing average

    See a monopolist which cannot price discriminate but that maximizes profit. When this firm produces the level of output where is average cost at its minimum that will charge a price: (i) equal to marginal cost and generate zero economic profit. (ii) e

  • Q : Substitution Effect-relative price of

    The substitution effect signifies to the change in consumption pattern as: (1) The absolute price of the good modifications. (2) Income changes. (3) The relative price of good changes. (4) The quality of good changes. Can someone p

  • Q : Reason of existence of firms Can

    Can someone please help me in finding out the accurate answer from the following question. The primary reasons for the existence of firms would not comprise: (1) Collecting sales taxes for government. (2) Entrepreneurial drives for the potential gains. (3) Cutting tra

  • Q : Illustration of Conglomerates I have a

    I have a problem in economics on Illustration of Conglomerates. Please help me in the following question. Prudential Insurance owns big farms in addition to its insurance operations, and is an illustration of: (1) Conglomerate. (2) Insurance fraud. (3) Monopoly. (4) H

  • Q : Minimum legal price in intersection of

    When a minimum legal price of a good is set below the intersection of the supply and demand curves there will be: (1) shortages and pressures for decreases in price. (2) pressures for increases in price and the emergence of black mark

  • Q : Changes in market prices and conditions

    The model of pure competitive is intended to produce insights within how: (w) asymmetric information influences the efficiency of exchange. (x) buyers and sellers negotiate to reach contracts for goods and services. (y) markets determine equitable dis