--%>

Testing Functional structure models

Testing Functional structure models: It is often hard to tell whether the functional model structure chosen (which almost always in published work appears to generate consistent and robust results) is the only one tested or not.

Leamer (1983) has argued that good method should require that authors report how many regressions they undertook (and the functional forms subsequently rejected) before they found the one they chose to report. Leamer is particularly concerned that authors often will do hundreds or thousands of regressions (involving an array of functional forms and manipulations of assumptions and data) before they find one that offers statistically significant results. He believes that presenting only the one that worked, instead of talking about the hundreds or thousands that didn’t work is incomplete reporting and can lead to spurious results or at least misapplied confidence in the results.

He illustrates using an example of fertilizer usage on farms that multiple functional forms can work (i.e. a linear relationship or a quadratic relationship with either increasing or decreasing returns to scale). In many cases there is not enough data (or degrees of freedom) to properly test the functional forms and select among them (what he calls the “identification problem”).

He believes the job of any researcher is “to report economically and informatively the mapping from assumptions into inferences”, identifying which forms are accepted or rejected and why. By this he hopes researchers can reduce the “whimsical character of econometric inference.”

   Related Questions in Microeconomics

  • Q : Examples of Complementary Goods Can

    Can someone help me in finding out the right answer from the given options. Illustrations of complementary goods would not comprise: (1) Football tickets and rugby tickets. (2) Golf clubs and golf balls. (3) Laundry detergent and washing machines. (4)

  • Q : Variation in supply and demand curves

    These supply and demand curves for housing do NOT involve that the: (w) demand for housing has increased. (x) supply has increased, because rental price has risen. (y) equilibrium price and quantity of housing have increased. (z) housing market will c

  • Q : Rate of Return on Investment When the

    When the rate of return on investment equals the interest rate, in that case the optimal level of investment will: (w) rise. (x) fall. (y) not change. (z) Any of the above is possible.

    Q : Problem on fast food chains market

    Normal 0 false false

  • Q : Consumers for Mortgage Funds Not in

    Not in between the total demands for loanable funds would be the demands of: (1) consumers for financial capital. (2) business firms for financial capital. (3) government for loanable funds to cover budget deficits. (4) consumers for mortgage funds. (

  • Q : Differentiate perfect and monopoly

    Differentiate between perfect competition and monopoly competition?

  • Q : Perfect Equality of Income Distribution

    A Lorenz curve which is identical to a 45 degree line by the origin indicates as: (w) perfect equality of income distribution. (x) complete inequality of income distribution. (y) unitarily elastic supplies of labor. (z) which poverty is prevalent.

  • Q : Market power and market inefficiency

    This is socially undesirable for a monopolist to produce where the price exceeds to marginal social cost [P > MSC] since: (w) resources are allocated inefficiently since too small is produced. (x) too many resources are used and production is exces

  • Q : Persistence of Economic profits in long

    I have a problem in economics on Persistence of Economic profits in long run. Please help me in the following question. Economic profits will continue in long run only when: (i) There are barriers to the entry and exit. (ii) Markets are much competitive. (iii) There a

  • Q : Diminishing Marginal utility principle

    Can someone help me in finding out the right answer from the given options. The experience that your very first kiss with a latest crush was more thrilling and satisfying than your 10th kiss 35 minutes later is an illustration of the: (i) Familiarity principle. (ii) N