--%>

Purchaing or leasing problem

Crawford Corporation is planning to lease a machine for the next 4 years for an annual lease payment of $3,000 paid in advance, plus a non-refundable initial fee of $3,000. There is a 1-year delay for the tax benefits of leasing. Crawford may buy the machine, depreciate it fully over the next 4 years, and then sell it for 10% of the purchase price. Crawford can borrow the money at 9% interest rate to finance the purchase, and its tax rate is 30%. Compute the price of the machine, which will make purchasing or leasing to be equally costly.

E

Expert

Verified

If the company has to be indifferent to leasing or buying, the net present value has to be set at zero. Let I be the price of machine. The after-tax cost of borrowing is 9% (1 – 0.3) = 6.3%.

Depreciation tax shield lost = (I/4)*0.3 = 0.075I
Payment shield = 3000*0.3 = $900
NPV = 0
I – 3000 – 3000 – (3000)(2.658)  + (900 - 0.075I)*3.44 – 0.07I*0.7832 = 0
I – 6000 – 5582.31 – 0.258I – 0.0548I = 0
0.687I = 10877.44
I = $15,831.66

   Related Questions in Corporate Finance

  • Q : Compute betas against local indexes

    Does it make any sense to compute betas against local indexes while a company has a great part of its operations outside such local market? I have two illustrations: BBVA and Santander.

  • Q : Walt disney WAAC You work in Walt

    You work in Walt Disney Company’s corporate finance and treasury department and have just been assigned to the team estimating Disney’s WACC. You must estimate this WACC in preparation for a team meeting later today....?

  • Q : Explain realization of name valuation

    I suppose that a valuation consciously realized in my name tells me how much I have to offer for the company, am I right?

  • Q : Benefits of working capital requirement

    Benefits of working capital requirement estimation: • Helps to judge the efficiency of utilization of working capital in generation of sales • Cost of capital aspect

  • Q : Discounting Free Cash Flow or

    Which of these two ways is better: discounting the Free Cash Flow or discounting the Equity Cash Flow?

  • Q : Difference between capitalization and

    Is the difference for the value creation in a company among the market value of the shares (capitalization) and their book value a good measure since its foundation?

  • Q : What are Stock exchanges Stock

    Stock exchanges: A stock exchange provides services useful for trading, issue and redemption of shares and other securities for traders and brokers. They will also provide facility for payment of income and dividends for listed securities. Securities

  • Q : Effective annual yield problem Stanley

    Stanley invested in a municipal bond which promised an annual yield of 6.7 %. The bond pays coupons twice a year. What is the effective annual yield (abbreviated as EAY) on this investment? (1) 13.4%  (2) 6.81%  (3) 6.70%  (4) None of the above

  • Q : Illustrates financial consultant has

    A financial consultant obtains various valuations of my company when this discounts the Free Cash Flow (FCF) as opposed to when this uses the Equity Cash Flow. Is it correct?

  • Q : Explain new methodology of standard

    Explain new methodology of standard market practice.