--%>

Purchaing or leasing problem

Crawford Corporation is planning to lease a machine for the next 4 years for an annual lease payment of $3,000 paid in advance, plus a non-refundable initial fee of $3,000. There is a 1-year delay for the tax benefits of leasing. Crawford may buy the machine, depreciate it fully over the next 4 years, and then sell it for 10% of the purchase price. Crawford can borrow the money at 9% interest rate to finance the purchase, and its tax rate is 30%. Compute the price of the machine, which will make purchasing or leasing to be equally costly.

E

Expert

Verified

If the company has to be indifferent to leasing or buying, the net present value has to be set at zero. Let I be the price of machine. The after-tax cost of borrowing is 9% (1 – 0.3) = 6.3%.

Depreciation tax shield lost = (I/4)*0.3 = 0.075I
Payment shield = 3000*0.3 = $900
NPV = 0
I – 3000 – 3000 – (3000)(2.658)  + (900 - 0.075I)*3.44 – 0.07I*0.7832 = 0
I – 6000 – 5582.31 – 0.258I – 0.0548I = 0
0.687I = 10877.44
I = $15,831.66

   Related Questions in Corporate Finance

  • Q : Porters Secondary activities Porter's

    Porter's Secondary activities: 1. Procurement: • Identification process of raw material.• Identification process of identifying probable suppliers.• Process of purchasing and calling quotes. 2. Human Resource management:

  • Q : Is this better to repurchase shares or

    Assuming a company needs to distribute money to shareholders of it, is this better to repurchase shares or to distribute dividends?

  • Q : Explain the way of estimating an average

    Explain the way of estimating an average.

  • Q : WCR lower cost of storage Inventory is

    Inventory is an important part of WCR estimation. It is a current asset, which depletes over period of time. Also, it requires creation of facility, which would help in storing the inventory and estimate the associated cost of maintaining and transporting it. The esti

  • Q : How you can predict future evolution of

    Could we suppose that, as we cannot predict the future evolution of the value of shares, a good estimation would be to consider this constant during the next five years?

  • Q : Is ROE a correct measurement of return

    The ROE is the ratio among net income and Shareholders’ equity. The meaning of Return on Equity is return to shareholders. Therefore, is ROE a correct measurement of the return to shareholders?

  • Q : Why required return cannot computed by

    Why can we not compute the required return (Ke) by the Gordon-Shapiro model [P0 = Div0 (1+g) / (Ke – g)] in place of using the CAPM? As we identify the current dividend (Div0) and the current share price (P0), we can acquire the growth rate of the dividend by th

  • Q : Discretion can distort results Discuss

    Discuss how management’s discretion in applying accounting rules can mislead investors. Provide three examples and how the discretion can distort results?

  • Q : Problem on required rate of return

    Tudor Online Publishing Corporation has tax rate of 35%, debt-to-equity ratio of 25%, and has (leveraged) beta 1.25. The riskless rate is 3% and the market return is 12%. Windsor Publishing Company is an all equity company and is in the same business. What is the requ

  • Q : Estimate stock's current price A

    A company currently pays a dividend of $3.75 per share, D0 = 3.75. It is estimated that the company's dividend will grow at a rate of 15% percent per year for the next 2 years, then the dividend will grow at a constant rate of 7% the