--%>

Purchaing or leasing problem

Crawford Corporation is planning to lease a machine for the next 4 years for an annual lease payment of $3,000 paid in advance, plus a non-refundable initial fee of $3,000. There is a 1-year delay for the tax benefits of leasing. Crawford may buy the machine, depreciate it fully over the next 4 years, and then sell it for 10% of the purchase price. Crawford can borrow the money at 9% interest rate to finance the purchase, and its tax rate is 30%. Compute the price of the machine, which will make purchasing or leasing to be equally costly.

E

Expert

Verified

If the company has to be indifferent to leasing or buying, the net present value has to be set at zero. Let I be the price of machine. The after-tax cost of borrowing is 9% (1 – 0.3) = 6.3%.

Depreciation tax shield lost = (I/4)*0.3 = 0.075I
Payment shield = 3000*0.3 = $900
NPV = 0
I – 3000 – 3000 – (3000)(2.658)  + (900 - 0.075I)*3.44 – 0.07I*0.7832 = 0
I – 6000 – 5582.31 – 0.258I – 0.0548I = 0
0.687I = 10877.44
I = $15,831.66

   Related Questions in Corporate Finance

  • Q : WCR fend off takeover bid WCR fend off

    WCR fend off takeover bid: The WCR estimation ensures that a firm takes corrective action in time to correct its WC status. This ensures that the firm is always in a positive WC status. In other words, the firm will be able to pay off all its short-te

  • Q : International financial what can we

    what can we expanded opportinity set of international finance?

  • Q : Active versus Passive fund managers

    Active vs. Passive fund managers: Passive fund managers adopt a long term buy and hold strategy. Usually, stocks are purchased so that the portfolio’s returns will track those of an

  • Q : Is the price of futures the excellent

    Is the price of futures the excellent estimate of €/$ exchange rate?

  • Q : Benefits of working capital requirement

    Benefits of working capital requirement estimation: • Helps to judge the efficiency of utilization of working capital in generation of sales • Cost of capital aspect

  • Q : Zurich Pvt Ltd. You have joined Zurich

    You have joined Zurich Pvt. Ltd as a Finance manager. You are given the following information: Zurich Pvt Ltd. is a diversified manufacturing firm dealing with electrical appliances. In 2012, the firm reported an operating income of Rs. 857.60 million and faced a tax rate of 35% on income. The firm

  • Q : Real estate problem Eric Rowan is

    Eric Rowan is planning to buy a house for $155,000 by borrowing money at the rate of 9%. He expects to rent the house for 5 years, collecting $20,000 annual rent in advance each year. He thinks that he can sell the house for $175,000 after five years. Fulton has incom

  • Q : Is net income of a year is doubtful for

    Is the net income of a year money the company made that given year or is this a number whose importance is quite doubtful?

  • Q : Bank assignment You have just been

    You have just been hired as the branch manager for a big bank in XYZ. You were told that the bank is going to open a new branch at Island Learning Centre of the Open University of XYZ. The management of the bank is much concerned that the new branch might not be able

  • Q : Cost of capital You have joined Zurich

    You have joined Zurich Pvt. Ltd as a Finance manager. You are given the following information: Zurich Pvt Ltd. is a diversified manufacturing firm dealing with electrical appliances. In 2012, the firm reported an operating income of Rs. 857.60 million and faced a tax rate of 35% on income. The