--%>

Purchaing or leasing problem

Crawford Corporation is planning to lease a machine for the next 4 years for an annual lease payment of $3,000 paid in advance, plus a non-refundable initial fee of $3,000. There is a 1-year delay for the tax benefits of leasing. Crawford may buy the machine, depreciate it fully over the next 4 years, and then sell it for 10% of the purchase price. Crawford can borrow the money at 9% interest rate to finance the purchase, and its tax rate is 30%. Compute the price of the machine, which will make purchasing or leasing to be equally costly.

E

Expert

Verified

If the company has to be indifferent to leasing or buying, the net present value has to be set at zero. Let I be the price of machine. The after-tax cost of borrowing is 9% (1 – 0.3) = 6.3%.

Depreciation tax shield lost = (I/4)*0.3 = 0.075I
Payment shield = 3000*0.3 = $900
NPV = 0
I – 3000 – 3000 – (3000)(2.658)  + (900 - 0.075I)*3.44 – 0.07I*0.7832 = 0
I – 6000 – 5582.31 – 0.258I – 0.0548I = 0
0.687I = 10877.44
I = $15,831.66

   Related Questions in Corporate Finance

  • Q : Active versus Passive fund managers

    Active vs. Passive fund managers: Passive fund managers adopt a long term buy and hold strategy. Usually, stocks are purchased so that the portfolio’s returns will track those of an

  • Q : All rates are stated annually with

    1 Assume the following (all rates are stated annually with semiannual compounding) a. Six Month Spot Rate is 2% b. Six Month Forward rate starting at month six is 2.2% c. Six Month Forward rate starting at month 12 is 2.4% d. Six Month Forward rate starting at mont

  • Q : Explain breakthroughs on

    Explain breakthroughs on low-discrepancy sequences.

  • Q : What is Box Spread Box Spread: This is

    Box Spread: This is another strategy which seeks to exploit the arbitrage opportunities which are available in the market. In case that the options are correctly priced, this strategy would earn only the risk free rate. However, due to existence of im

  • Q : Difference between capitalization and

    Is the difference for the value creation in a company among the market value of the shares (capitalization) and their book value a good measure since its foundation?

  • Q : Benefits of Cash to cash analysis

    Benefits of Cash to cash analysis: The benefits of Cash to cash analysis are as following: 1. Helps in better cash management situation thus, increasing liquidity. 2. The cash a

  • Q : In which cases use different WACCs Is

    Is this possible to use different WACCs within order to discount each year’s flows? In which cases?

  • Q : Case Study 2 You have joined Zurich

    You have joined Zurich Pvt. Ltd as a Finance manager. You are given the following information: Zurich Pvt Ltd. is a diversified manufacturing firm dealing with electrical appliances. In 2012, the firm reported an operating income of Rs. 857.60 million and faced a tax rate of 35% on income. The firm

  • Q : Define Capital Projects Capital

    Capital Projects: It is a long-term investment made in order to build on, add or enhance on a capital-intensive project. A capital project is any undertaking that requires the usage of notable amounts of capital, together with financial and labor, to

  • Q : Explain few Spanish mutual funds

    Is this true that very little Spanish mutual funds outperform their benchmark? Isn’t this strange?