--%>

Merger and acquisition of firms operating

Question:

Suppose firm 1 and firm 2 merge. Call the new firm A. It has output xA and profit πA. Suppose there is Cournot competition after the merger. For now, we assume that the marginal cost of Firm A, the merged firm, still is 40 (the same as firm 3).

e) Compute quantities for both the merged firm and firm 3. Also, compute the market price and profits.

f) Is the total quantity produced (and sold) larger or smaller than before?

g) Compare the initial sum of profits of the two individual firms, π1 + π2, with the profits of the merged firm, πA. Explain and comment.

If the merged firm were able to exploit economies of scale it would affect costs, maybe even marginal costs. Assume that the marginal cost of the merged firm (only!) was not 40, but 30.

h) Is the merger profitable in this case? What happens to the non-merged firm's (firm 3) profits compared to the original situation with 3 firms?

i) Can you say something about how much reduction in the merged firm's MC must be able to achieve for the merger to become profitable?

j) Relate this to a real-world merger. Are they usually profitable? Can you give examples? Are there other things to consider than marginal cost?

Summary:

Questions related to the previous scenario of 3 firms is continued in this answer. The question is that if two firms in the Cornout market merge into one firm, what would the merger result in? how much of marginal cost would prevail in the market, etc are answered in a detailed in manner in the solution.

Answer:

(a)    P = 200- xa-   x3

ð  Pxa = 200xa - xa2 - xax3

ð  MRa = 200 - 2xa - x3

under FOC,

200 - 2xa - x3 = 40

ð  xa = (160 - x3)/2

Again, due to symmetry, xa = x3

ð  xa = (160 - xa)/2

ð  xa = 160/3 = x3

ð  X = 320/3

ð  P = 200 - 320/3 = 280/3

ð  πa = π3 = (280/3)*(160/3) - (160/3)*40 = 25600/9

ð  π= 51200/9

(b)   X = 120 and X' (new level) = 320/3

Clearly, X'< X

(c)    π1 + π2 = 3200

πa = 25600/ 9 = 2844.44

The profits of the merged firm are below that of the sum of the individual firms earlier. This happens mainly because of the fact while total production decreases; there is no decrease in the cost of production. The price has increased, but the effect of decline in quantity sold exceeds that of the increase in price.

If the merged firm were able to exploit economies of scale it would affect costs, maybe even marginal costs. Assume that the marginal cost of the merged firm (only!) was not 40, but 30.

(d)   The reaction curve of firm A now becomes:

xa = (170-x3)/2

The reaction curve of firm 3 is:

x3 = (160 - xa)/2

Solving it, we find:

xa = 60 and x3 = 50

Therefore, P = 200 - 110 = 90

Therefore, πa = 90*60 - 30*60 = 3600 and π3 = 50*90 - 40*50 = 2500

The profit of both, firm A and 3, increases.

(e)    Suppose marginal cost for A = n

Then the reaction functions are:

xa = (200-n-x3)/2

The reaction curve of firm 3 is:

x3 = (160 - xa)/2

Solving it,

xa = (240-2n)/3, x3 = (240+2n)/6

Therefore, x = (360 - n)/3

Therefore, P = 200 - (360 - n)/3

ð  P = (240 +n)/3

Now, for firm A,

{(240 +n)/3}*{(240-2n)/3} - {(240-2n)/3}*n = 3200

ð  (240-2n)/3 [(240 +n)/3 - n] = 3200

ð  (240 -2n)2 = 3200*9

ð  240 - 2n = 169.7

ð  n = 35.15

So, below the MC of 35.15, the firm will make more profits than earlier.

(f)    Mergers usually happen between the firms which are equal level of revenue. Also, they are usually profitable but not always. The merger of Towers Perrin and Watson Wyatt in 2010 is an excellent example which shows how the profits increase after merger.

However, transition and management changes are also important apart from marginal cost. The management and work ethics transitions have to be smooth so that the functioning of the firm in general and productivity of the workers in particular is not adversely affected. 

   Related Questions in Macroeconomics

  • Q : Value of fiscal deficit Evaluate the

    Evaluate the value of fiscal deficit when primary deficit is 53,000 crores and interest on borrowings is Rs 5,000 crores?

  • Q : Decisions at the Margin The least

    The least apparent illustration of how decisions are generally ‘at the margin’ would be: (i) Purchasing an additional novel after learning that all paper-backs at Borders are on sale for 25 percent off. (ii) Tossing a 6-year old cousin to the deep end of t

  • Q : IS-KM Model with classical supply

    discuss with the help of IS-LM model why money has no effect on output in classical supply case

  • Q : Define Macro Economics Macro Economics

    Macro Economics: Macro economics studies the economy as an entire.

  • Q : Explain Tax rate increase. A change in

    A change in tax rate changes the IS equation, LM equation remaining the same. Let same, let us suppose that the government raises the tax rate from 20 percent to 25 percent<

  • Q : Article on Agriculture and economic

    Read the article on blackboard in the assignments area, John McCallum "Agriculture and economic development in Ontario and Quebec until 1870", Gordon Laxer, ed. Perspectives on Canadian Economic Development: Class, Staples, Gender and Elites (Toronto: Oxford Universit

  • Q : Consumption curve Illustrate a point on

    Illustrate a point on consumption curve at which APC = 1. Answer: APC = C/Y = 1 is possible when C = Y, that is, Consumption is

  • Q : Role of price in market economies What

    What is the role of price in market economies?

  • Q : Value of total receipts of government

    Determine the value of total receipts of government budget when budget deficit is Rs 2,000 crores and the net expenses is Rs 3,000 crores.

  • Q : Greatest Consumer Surplus problem I

    I have a problem in economics on Greatest Consumer Surplus. Please help me in the following question. Usual Americans undoubtedly derive the greatest consumer surpluses from the: (i) Summer vacations. (ii) Jelly and Peanut butter. (iii) Gold jewellery