--%>

Legal Reasoning and Writing

 

This exercise does not require you to do any research, and does not require you to cite to any references or external materials.  Do not include any constitutional arguments.

Like many legal and policy questions, the question you must answer for this exercise does not have any right or wrong answer.  Your answer will be graded on your use of reasoning and argument, and clarity of writing.

In answering the question, follow carefully the principles set out in the class handout, "Handout on Legal Reasoning and Writing," and subsequently discussed in class. 

You are helping Mr. LaLumier'slawyer. Please select the one best argument for his defense and analyze it.  In writing your essay, use the techniques described in the class handout called, "Handout on Legal Reasoning and Writing."

Assignment 

The South Caledonia Rail System has the following official rule on its books:

"Live animals of greater than six pounds in weight shall be allowed on train cars if the master of the animalpurchases a full-fare ticket.  Live animals that weigh 6 pounds or less may be carried on a train car in a bag or basket if the master of the animal purchases a half-fare ticket for each animal."

Mr. Lance LaLumiere was discovered by the train conductor to be carrying seven live oysters in a basket, which he intended to eat for his lunch on the train. He had not purchased a ticket for any of the oysters and he was fined $500 for transporting live animals under 6 pounds in weight without purchasing a ticket.

He is appealing the fine in court.

 

 

 

 

 

   Related Questions in Financial Accounting

  • Q : Trading A CD/$ bank trader is presently

    A CD/$ bank trader is presently quoting a small figure bid-ask of 35-40, while rest of the market is trading at the CD1.3436-CD1.3441.  Specify what all is implied about trader’s beliefs by his prices?

  • Q : Major reasons of current account

    In contrast to the U.S., Japan has observed constant current account surpluses. What would be the major reasons for such surpluses? Is it advantageous to have constant current account surpluses?

  • Q : Help Otobai Motor Company is currently

    Otobai Motor Company is currently paying a dividend of $1.40 per year. The dividends are expected to grow at a rate of 18% for the next three years and then a constant rate of 5% thereafter forever. What is the value of its current stock price? Assuming that the discount rate is 10%.

  • Q : Swap broker and swap dealer State the

    State the difference between the swap broker and the swap dealer.

  • Q : What is Triangular arbitrage What is

    What is meant by the Triangular arbitrage?  Explain about the condition which provides rise to opportunity of the triangular arbitrage?

  • Q : Issuing dual currency bonds What

    What borrower must consider before issuing the dual currency bonds?

  • Q : Describe Short Holding Period Describe

    Describe Short Holding Period briefly with suitable example?

  • Q : Explain the term Insolvent Explain the

    Explain the term Insolvent in brief associating to debt?

  • Q : Architectural Symbolism-house-style

    Wriet a report on the term Architectural Symbolism:a study of house-style meanings ?

  • Q : What bid price per widget should you

    You are required to submit a bid to supply 200,000,000 widgets per year to the State of Illinois for the next five years. Your company has an idle tract of real estate that cost $1,500,000 ten years ago; if your company sold the land