--%>
Assignment Help - homework help

How present value of tax shields be calculated

I have two valuations of the company that we set as an objective. Within one of them, the present value of tax shields (D Kd T) computed using Ku (required return to unlevered equity) and, in one, by using Kd (required return to debt). The second valuation is too higher than the first one, but here which of the two is better?

E

Expert

Verified

Fernández (2001) demonstrates that discounting the tax shields along with the Ku and the WACC is not right. There are six habitual expressions to compute the value of tax shields that are frequently used. Just three of them are valid (they have a theoretical origin):

Myers (1974) and Modigliani-Miller (1963), while the company plans to return the existing debt without making a newest one; Miles-Ezzell (1980) while the company plans its debt proportionally to market value of shares; and also Fernández (2004), while the company plans its debt proportionally to book value of the assets or shares.

Fernández (2004): VTS = VA [D Ku T; Ku].

Miles-Ezzell (1980): VA[Ku; D T Kd] (1+Ku)/ (1+Kd)

Myers (1974) and Modigliani-Miller (1963): VTS = VA[Kd; D T Kd]. Other incorrect formulae to calculate the value of tax shields are:

Damodaran (1994): VA [Ku; DTKu – D (Kd – RF) (1–T)];

Practitioners: VA [Ku; DTKd – D(Kd – RF)]

Harris-Pringle (1985) y Ruback (1995, 2002): VA [Ku; D T Kd]

Myers (1974) has to be used only while it is possible to know with whole certainty the amount of the debt at any future instant. Miles y Ezzell (1980) has to be used only when the future debt is proportional to market value of the shares that we are not aware of any company which manages its debt in such a way. Fernández (2004) has to be used only when the risk of the future raise of the debt is the same to that of the FCF.

   Related Questions in Corporate Finance

  • Q : Problem on binomial option pricing model

    The share price of Cheung Kong (Holdings) Limited is currently at $100. Over each of the next two three-month periods, you expect its price will either increase by 10% or fall by 10% in each three-month period. If the Hong Kong interbank offered rate is 8% per annum w

    		•
  • Q : Widgets You are required to submit a

    You are required to submit a bid to supply 200,000,000 widgets per year to the State of Illinois for the next five years. Your company has an idle tract of real estate that cost $1,500,000 ten years ago; if your company sold the land today, it would generate $3,000,000 after the taxes were paid. The

    		•
  • Q : Tax credit for lease payments problem

    ABC Inc. is planning to lease a computer for $3000 per annum, payable in advance, for a period of 4 years. The lease will cover maintenance costs. ABC CFO feels that if he buys the same computer he should be able to sell it at 15% of the purchase price after 4 years.

    		•
  • Q : Markets are expected to be Volatile

    When Markets are expected to be Volatile: For the bear and bull strategy to yield gains, it is essential that the trader takes a view on the direction of the market i.e. either bearish or bullish, and accordingly implement the strategic choice. More o

    		•
  • Q : Problem on Decision variables A factory

    A factory has three distinct systems for making similar product: System 1: Worker runs 3 machines of type-A, each of which costs $20 per day to run, each generates 100 units per day and the worker is paid $40 per day.System 2

    		•
  • Q : Financial statements The concept of

    The concept of conservatism has been influential in the development of accounting theory and practice.  A major effect of conservatism is that accountants tend to recognize losses but not gains.  For example, when the value of an asset is impaired, it is wri

    		•
  • Q : How could prestigious investment bank

    I have a doubt about the Enron case. How could this prestigious investment bank advice investing while the quotations of the shares were falling?

    		•
  • Q : Financial problem regarding acquistion

    My Company paid an extremely higher price for the acquisition of other company; the price was recommended through the valuation of an investment bank. Now we have financial problems. So is there any way to make this bank legally responsible for such situation?

    		•
  • Q : Price per share for Corporation For XYZ

    For XYZ Corporation debt-to-equity ratio, marginal tax rate, and dividend payout ratio are all of 40%. The cost of debt is 10%. Cambria contains 1 million shares of common stock, and $25 million in long-term bonds. Its dividend is $1 per share. Determine the EBIT and

    		•
  • Q : Calculate valuation realized by

    Is a valuation realized through a prestigious investment bank a scientifically approved result that any investor could utilize as a reference?

    		•