--%>

Discretion can distort results

Discuss how management’s discretion in applying accounting rules can mislead investors. Provide three examples and how the discretion can distort results?

E

Expert

Verified

If there were no accounting standards and no law to dictate the accounting principles and policies then there would not be a single financial statement without any manipulation.

If the management has their own discretion in applying accounting rules then they would always prepare accounts in a way which will be beneficial for them. They will prepare accounts so as to mislead stock holders, investors, lenders and can pocket huge amount.

Suppose if a company is following straight line method of depreciation then if they were no restriction on applying a method consistently then, the management could have a good opportunity to apply different method of depreciation each year as per their requirement either to increase profit or decrease profit. They would identify the method which is beneficial for them in the given situation and would apply them and no one can make out this fraud going in the company.

Secondly, for example if a company is following accrual method of accounting it has to follow accrual method only. There can be an instance where management has  purchased huge stock irrespective of the need of the company ,may be for his own interest, and he can then apply cash method of accounting and can show purchases as per the requirement of the company and can adjust cash somewhere else.

Another example is in the valuation of inventories, if a company is using First in first out method or last in first out method or weighted average method then it has to use it consistently. Otherwise, management is always in the possession to manipulate accounts in their favour, thereby misleading, users of financial statements. Incorrect value of inventories, cost of goods sold can change the profit actually earned by the company.

A financial analyst should be aware that different accounting methods employed by different firms and by the similar firm in different years complicate comparisons. Financial ratios, for illustration, will differ whenever different accounting methods are employed, even when there are no dissimilarities in attributes being compared. Investors and Creditors also need to be alert to instances in which companies change accounting methods. Managers try to compensate for downturn in the actual performance by changing the method which will help them to increase the profit.

   Related Questions in Corporate Finance

  • Q : Selling or purchasing problem Atlas

    Atlas Realty Company is interested in buying a house and renting it out for $12,000 a year, collecting the rent in advance each year. This will depreciate the house over 25 years; however sell it after 15 years at twice its purchase price. The maintenance expenditures

  • Q : When the dividend shows real money The

    The dividend is the part of the net income which the company distributes to shareholders. When the dividend shows real money, the net income is also real money. Is it true?

  • Q : Explain undervaluation of share on the

    Suppose we calculate g as ROE (1–p)/(1–ROE (1–p)) and the Ke by the CAPM. We replace both values into the formula PER = (ROE (1+g) – g)/ROE (Ke-g) but there PER we obtain is fully different from the one we get by dividing the quotation of the s

  • Q : Explain useful properties of

    Explain useful properties of low-discrepancy sequence theory or quasi random number theory.

  • Q : Abnormal profits based on fundamental

    If it is possible to make abnormal profits based on fundamental analysis, you can conclude that the market is: A) Not weak-form efficientB) Weak-form efficientC) Not semi-strong-form efficientD) Semi-strong-form e

  • Q : Problem on Yield to maturity Shawna

    Shawna desires to invest her recent bonus in a 4-year bond which pays a coupon of 11 % semi-annually. The bonds are selling at $962.13 nowadays. When she buys such bond and holds it to the maturity, what would be her yield? (Round to the nearest answer.) (i) 11.5%&nbs

  • Q : How must we compute the beta and the

    How must we compute the beta and the risk premium?

  • Q : Valuation & Merger analysis Problem

    Problem 21-1 Valuation Harrison Corporation is interested in acquiring Van Buren Corporation. Assume t

  • Q : Which parameter good measures value

    Which parameter good measures value creation; the Economic Value Added (EVA), the CVA (Cash Value Added) or the economic profit?

  • Q : Capital Structure Case Study 1 You work

    Case Study 1 You work in Walt Disney Company's corporate finance and treasury department and have just been assigned to the team estimating later today. You quickly realize that the information you need is readily available online. 1) Go to http://finance.yahoo.com. under " Market Summary," you