--%>

Discretion can distort results

Discuss how management’s discretion in applying accounting rules can mislead investors. Provide three examples and how the discretion can distort results?

E

Expert

Verified

If there were no accounting standards and no law to dictate the accounting principles and policies then there would not be a single financial statement without any manipulation.

If the management has their own discretion in applying accounting rules then they would always prepare accounts in a way which will be beneficial for them. They will prepare accounts so as to mislead stock holders, investors, lenders and can pocket huge amount.

Suppose if a company is following straight line method of depreciation then if they were no restriction on applying a method consistently then, the management could have a good opportunity to apply different method of depreciation each year as per their requirement either to increase profit or decrease profit. They would identify the method which is beneficial for them in the given situation and would apply them and no one can make out this fraud going in the company.

Secondly, for example if a company is following accrual method of accounting it has to follow accrual method only. There can be an instance where management has  purchased huge stock irrespective of the need of the company ,may be for his own interest, and he can then apply cash method of accounting and can show purchases as per the requirement of the company and can adjust cash somewhere else.

Another example is in the valuation of inventories, if a company is using First in first out method or last in first out method or weighted average method then it has to use it consistently. Otherwise, management is always in the possession to manipulate accounts in their favour, thereby misleading, users of financial statements. Incorrect value of inventories, cost of goods sold can change the profit actually earned by the company.

A financial analyst should be aware that different accounting methods employed by different firms and by the similar firm in different years complicate comparisons. Financial ratios, for illustration, will differ whenever different accounting methods are employed, even when there are no dissimilarities in attributes being compared. Investors and Creditors also need to be alert to instances in which companies change accounting methods. Managers try to compensate for downturn in the actual performance by changing the method which will help them to increase the profit.

   Related Questions in Corporate Finance

  • Q : Assessing market expectations using CAPM

    Assume that the risk-free rate is 1% and the expected market return is 9%. You are considering purchasing Super Soft stock, which currently sells for $100 a share and will pay its next (annual) dividend of $1.00 exactly one year from today. Super Soft is considered to

  • Q : What are capital investment The capital

    The capital investment appraisal techniques such as NPV, IRR, ARR, PV and Time value of money have become irrelevant post Celtic Tiger. Due to the depth of the recession companies do not have budgets to invest. Discus First use this information when you are writing this essay: 1.&

  • Q : Problem on Bank branch networks While

    While banks across the United States and Europe are cutting down their number of branches, the number of bank branches in Hong Kong has increased in the same period. Hong Kong Monetary Authority statistics show the number of bank branches in Hong Kong at the end of 20

  • Q : Illustrates financial consultant has

    A financial consultant obtains various valuations of my company when this discounts the Free Cash Flow (FCF) as opposed to when this uses the Equity Cash Flow. Is it correct?

  • Q : Problem on raising new capital AB

    AB Corporation has 3 million shares of common stock selling at $19 each. It also contains $25 million in bonds with coupon rate of 8%, selling at par. AB requires $10 million in new capital that it can raise by selling stock at $18, or bonds at 9% interest. The expect

  • Q : Data Case Please Assist with the

    Please Assist with the attached Data Case Assignment

  • Q : Cost of Equity AB Corporation has 16%

    AB Corporation has 16% cost of equity, 35% tax rate, and debt-to-equity ratio of 30%. XY Corporation has 30% tax rate and debt-to-equity ratio of 40%. Both AB and XY are in the same business of selling automotive parts. If the riskless rate is 4% and the expected retu

  • Q : Difference between capitalization and

    Is the difference for the value creation in a company among the market value of the shares (capitalization) and their book value a good measure since its foundation?

  • Q : Probability of dividend Universal

    Universal Corporation has the following dividend policy: if the earnings after taxes are less than $1 million, the dividend payout ratio will be 35%, but if these earnings are over $1 million, the dividend payout ratio will be 45%. The EBIT of Universal for next year

  • Q : Bond Price Information What is Bond

    What is Bond Price Information: Answer: Corporate bond market is not considered to be much transparent as it trades predominantly over the counter and investors do n